ATT&CKProcedure examples

Procedure examples

Real-world descriptions of how a group, tool or campaign used a technique.

17636 examples

TechniqueUsed byProcedure example
T1657
Financial Theft
GroupThe Gentlemen

The Gentlemen has used double-extortion tactics to sway victims to pay a ransom to include exfiltrating sensitive data, encrypting files, and threatening public release if a payment is not received.

T1659
Content Injection
GroupMoustachedBouncer

MoustachedBouncer has injected content into DNS, HTTP, and SMB replies to redirect specifically-targeted victims to a fake Windows Update page to download malware.

T1659
Content Injection
MalwareDisco

Disco has achieved initial access and execution through content injection into DNS, HTTP, and SMB replies to targeted hosts that redirect them to download malicious files.

T1665
Hide Infrastructure
CampaignOperation Digital Eye

During Operation Digital Eye, threat actors used public Cloud infrastructure to mask malicious activity.

T1665
Hide Infrastructure
CampaignSolarWinds Compromise

During the SolarWinds Compromise, APT29 set the hostnames of their C2 infrastructure to match legitimate hostnames in the victim environment. They also used IP addresses originating from the same country as the victim for their VPN infrastructure.

T1665
Hide Infrastructure
CampaignQuad7 Activity

Quad7 Activity has rotated the compromised SOHO IPs used in password spraying activity to hamper detection and network blocking activities by defenders.

T1665
Hide Infrastructure
GroupZIRCONIUM

ZIRCONIUM has utilized an ORB (operational relay box) network – consisting compromised devices such as small office and home office (SOHO) routers, IoT devices, and leased virtual private servers (VPS) – to obfuscate the origin of C2 traffic.

T1665
Hide Infrastructure
GroupAPT29

APT29 uses compromised residential endpoints, typically within the same ISP IP address range, as proxies to hide the true source of C2 traffic.

T1665
Hide Infrastructure
MalwareJumbledPath

JumbledPath can use a chain of jump hosts to communicate with compromised devices to obscure actor infrastructure.

T1665
Hide Infrastructure
MalwareUPSTYLE

UPSTYLE attempts to retrieve a non-existent webpage from the command and control server resulting in hidden commands sent via resulting error messages.

T1665
Hide Infrastructure
MalwareDarkGate

DarkGate command and control includes hard-coded domains in the malware masquerading as legitimate services such as Akamai CDN or Amazon Web Services.

T1667
Email Bombing
GroupStorm-1811

Storm-1811 has deployed large volumes of non-malicious email spam to victims in order to prompt follow-on interactions with the threat actor posing as IT support or helpdesk to resolve the problem.

T1669
Wi-Fi Networks
CampaignAPT28 Nearest Neighbor Campaign

During APT28 Nearest Neighbor Campaign, APT28 established wireless connections to secure, enterprise Wi-Fi networks belonging to a target organization for initial access into the environment.

T1669
Wi-Fi Networks
GroupAPT28

APT28 has exploited open Wi-Fi access points for initial access to target devices using the network.

T1671
Cloud Application Integration
CampaignSalesforce Data Exfiltration

During Salesforce Data Exfiltration, threat actors deceived victims into authorizing malicious connected apps to their organization's Salesforce portal.

T1673
Virtual Machine Discovery
GroupUNC3886

UNC3886 has used scripts to enumerate ESXi hypervisors and their guest VMs.

T1673
Virtual Machine Discovery
MalwareCheerscrypt

Cheerscrypt has leveraged `esxcli vm process list` in order to gather a list of running virtual machines to terminate them.

T1673
Virtual Machine Discovery
MalwarePureCrypter

PureCrypter can identify virtual machines by querying the WMI object Win32_ComputerSystem for manufacturer and model and check it against the regular expression Microsoft|VMWare|Virtual.

T1673
Virtual Machine Discovery
MalwareVIRTUALPITA

VIRTUALPITA can target specific guest virtual machines for script execution.

T1673
Virtual Machine Discovery
MalwareQilin

Qilin can detect virtual machine environments including ESXi hosts, datacenters, and clusters within vCenter environments.

T1673
Virtual Machine Discovery
MalwareMiniBus

MiniBus has the ability to identify processes associated with virtual machine utilities.

T1674
Input Injection
GroupFIN7

FIN7 has used malicious USBs to emulate keystrokes to launch PowerShell to download and execute malware from the adversary's server.

T1675
ESXi Administration Command
GroupUNC3886

UNC3886 used `vmtoolsd.exe` to run commands on guest virtual machines from a compromised ESXi host.

T1675
ESXi Administration Command
MalwareVIRTUALPITA

VIRTUALPITA can execute commands on guest virtual machines from compromised ESXi hypervisors.

T1675
ESXi Administration Command
MalwareThe Gentlemen Ransomware

The Gentlemen Ransomware has utilized ESXi administration commands to include `vmkfstools` to modify the compromised system.

T1677
Poisoned Pipeline Execution
MalwareShai-Hulud

Shai-Hulud has also leveraged GitHub actions from stolen accounts in order to create a malicious Github workflow within `.github/workflows/discussion.yaml`.

T1677
Poisoned Pipeline Execution
MalwareMini Shai-Hulud

Mini Shai-Hulud has utilized Github Actions to propagate through the use of triggered workflows.

T1677
Poisoned Pipeline Execution
MalwareCanisterWorm

CanisterWorm has leveraged stolen tokens from Trivy users to publish itself across over 46 npm packages.

T1677
Poisoned Pipeline Execution
GroupTeamPCP

TeamPCP has compromised trusted CI/CD pipelines by injecting credential-stealing payloads into legitimate workflows and software packages including open-source security tools Trivy and KICS, and AI gateway LiteLLM.

T1677
Poisoned Pipeline Execution
GroupAPT38

APT38 has poisoned npm packages with fake runtime dependencies to trigger execution of malicious payloads on developer endpoints or continuous integration and continuous delivery (CI/CD) systems during npm installation or update.

T1678
Delay Execution
Campaign3CX Supply Chain Attack

During the 3CX Supply Chain Attack, AppleJeus's software generates a randomly selected date that is between 1-4 weeks in the future. This timestamp is then checked against the current time of the compromised machine, and the malware will sleep until that time is encountered.

T1678
Delay Execution
GroupKimsuky

Kimsuky has utilized the Sleep function to ensure execution of scripts.

T1678
Delay Execution
GroupMustang Panda

Mustang Panda has delayed the execution of payloads leveraging ping echo requests `cmd /c ping 8.8.8.8 -n 70&&"%temp%\<legitimate executable>"`.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareBRICKSTORM

BRICKSTORM has embedded delayed-start logic that attempts to circumvent detection for long-term persistence. BRICKSTORM has been observed configured with a “delay” timer built-in that waited for a hard-coded date months in the future before beginning to beacon to the configured C2 domain.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareTONESHELL

TONESHELL has the ability to pause operations for a specified duration prior to follow-on execution of activities.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareDynoWiper

DynoWiper has utilized a five-second delay using `Sleep(5000)` between two of the three phases of the attack that involves file overwriting, file deletion, and system reboot.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareSystemBC

SystemBC has leveraged the Sleep functions before and after commands to ensure execution using the hexadecimal values within commands to include `Sleep(0x2710u)` that waits 10 seconds, and `Sleep(0xEA60u)` for 60 seconds.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareRustyWater

RustyWater has generated random sleep intervals between C2 communication.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwarePureCrypter

PureCrypter has the ability to delay for a specified number of seconds before execution.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareMuddyViper

MuddyViper has the ability to sleep for a certain amount of time, with the default being one minute.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareFooder

Fooder has used a custom delay function (`delayExecution(integer)`) and Sleep API calls (`Sleep(integer)`) to slow code execution.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareGlassWorm

GlassWorm has used a timeout function set to `9e5` which delays execution 900,000 milliseconds or 15 minutes to avoid detection.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareAshTag

AshTag can use a set sleep time to delay C2 beaconing.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwarePHASEJAM

PHASEJAM has used the `sleep` command within its code to generate a fake HTML upgrade progress bar that mimics a running process.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareSPAWNCHIMERA

SPAWNCHIMERA has used delayed execution to pause for a defined interval before performing environment discovery, repeatedly checking for specific processes, such as the `dslogserver` process, prior to continuing execution.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareHIUPAN

HIUPAN has used a config file “$.ini” to store a sleep multiplier to execute at a set interval value prior to initiating a watcher function that checks for a specific running process, that checks for removable drives and installs itself and supporting files if one is available.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareShai-Hulud

Shai-Hulud has delayed execution of its larger payloads by forking itself into background process.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareQilin

Qilin has the ability to delay execution.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareUPPERCUT

UPPERCUT can use a sleep function to delay execution.

T1678
Delay Execution
MalwareTeamPCP Cloud Stealer

TeamPCP Cloud Stealer has leveraged a persistence script that will sleep for five minutes before additional execution.

Data from MITRE ATT&CK® (Enterprise). ATT&CK® is a registered trademark of The MITRE Corporation.